Published May 23, 2025

Inside Look: What $500K Buys You in Clay vs. St. Johns County

Author Avatar

Written by Becky Parker

Inside Look: What $500K Buys You in Clay vs. St. Johns County header image.

$500,000 can buy you a gorgeous home in Northeast Florida—but where you look changes everything. Here's what your money gets you in Clay vs. St. Johns.

  • Clay County: Larger lots, family-focused neighborhoods, newer builds. Example: 4-bed, 3-bath, 2,600 sq ft in Oakleaf.
  • St. Johns County: Top-rated schools, modern developments, tighter inventory. Example: 3-bed, 2-bath, 2,100 sq ft near Nocatee.
  • Commute & Lifestyle: Clay = more space, St. Johns = higher walkability and resale values.

Curious what fits your lifestyle and budget best? I’ll break it down for you—just ask!

Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Becky Parker

Operator | Love Florida Living Group | EXP Realty

Agent profile image in message

or another way